Showing posts with label Recording Industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recording Industry. Show all posts

Sunday, 3 June 2012

What's with this Kolaveri about John Doe Injunctions?


What's with this Kolaveri about John Doe Injunctions?


[This is a revised version of an article originally written for the Down to Earth website. While it may not pertain specifically to Shastriya Sangeet, I felt that the issues that it does address, viz. copyright and legal remedies against piracy, are tangibly enough related to the theme of this blog to merit this article's inclusion.]

On 29 March 2012, at the instance of a firm called Copyright Labs, the Madras High Court issued an injunction intended to prevent the illegal copying and distribution of the film "3", perhaps best known for it song "Why this kolaveri (killer rage)".  Those interested may read the order for themselves, (courtesy of the BGR blog); as injunctions go it was certainly a most unusual one. It was ex parte in nature, that is, it has been issued by hearing only one side. Moreover, it was in the nature of a "John Doe injunction", that is, it applied to any and all persons, even unknown ones. The plaintiffs used this feature to persuade ISPs to altogether block access to both P2P sites and video sharing sites like Vimeo and Dailymotion, regardless of whether or not they actually contained or gave access to the concerned material. Predictably, this caused outrage and confusion in equal measure. Even to someone like me who can claim some connection with the law for the last seventeen years, the incident did not make sense. How could an ex parte John Doe injunction of such sweeping ambit be ever contemplated? And how can an injunction to prevent piracy apply to ISPs and video sharing sites anyway?

To understand the facts better, perhaps the quickest strategy is to fall back on beer, the law student's time-tested analytical tool. Consider a situation (needless to say, completely hypothetical), where United Breweries discovers some enthusiasts brewing, on a limited scale, a beer near-identical to Kingfisher Ultra. Its purveyors have no intention of passing it off as genuine KF. Neither is this faux KF sold or transacted for material gain, but only "shared" amongst its (re)creators. At the same time, the purveyors are open about their product's resemblance to the genuine KF, and indeed their declared intention has been to recreate its taste and colour. Over time this community of enthusiasts starts cutting into UB's revenue, or at least UB claims so. The company tries to approach law courts, but it turns out  that the places where the sharing takes place lies beyond the the courts' jurisdiction. UB then takes out a court order forbidding anyone to help these exchanges. 'Anyone' means literally just about anybody. It includes not only sharing venues, but also certain clubs or societies where microbrewery enthusiasts gather to discuss and sample (not consume) each other's products. Since these sampling clubs also lie outside the court's jurisdiction, the injunction does not help UB much. Now what does it do? It goes and informs bus and taxi companies that the terms of the court order are so wide as to cover them also. Hence they are prohibited from carrying passengers to the sharing venues and sampling clubs. This prohibition extends even to passengers who have no interest in KF, but want to go to a sampling club to taste brews that have nothing at all to do with UB.

The natural response to this admittedly absurd scenario is that beer (and likewise chocolate, toothpaste or shoe polish) are inherently different from films or audio recordings. Replicating beer entails a process not only skilful but also cumbersome and expensive, which tends to restrict such not-for-profit endeavours to "small beer", literally. This is one major flaw in our above example: it is very difficult to sustain volumes large enough to dent UB's profit margins unless one resorts to outright fakery and passing off. In contrast, films can be easily copied and distributed over the internet at little to no cost.

But should this difference alone justify such sweeping injunctions and render plausible in respect of films what we just acknowledged as absurd in the case of beer? In other words, can certain procedures otherwise uncalled for be justified merely because the subject matter concerns intellectual property? This means the matter pertains not so much to copyright as it does to civil procedure and how it is to be applied to enforce rights deriving from intellectual property laws. This is a vast issue, well beyond the scope of this article.  Here I shall only raise a few points that I consider germane.

Protecting intellectual property, and particularly copyrights, presents an unprecedented challenge to legal systems the world over. Advances in digital technology has made it possible to copy and distribute over the internet music recordings, films and even books with unprecedented speeds and reach. Despite many efforts, no satisfactory legal response has been devised so far. "Satisfactory" is a loaded term, so it is perhaps a good idea to specify what exactly I mean by it. First, it must bear strong connections with the idea of efficiency, that is, securing the objective with minimal wasted effort and "collateral damage". The last is particularly significant. Applied to the present context, it means simply that the measure must (a) be effective in restricting piracy, and (b) cannot be so broad in its ambit as to encroach upon individuals' legimitate interests. This includes the various fair use rights recognised under S. 52 of the Copyright Act; the right to access on Vimeo and Dailymotion videos that have been legally uploaded there; and even the right to distribute over BitTorrent material whose copyright status is not in dispute (I myself have used BitTorrent on several occasions to download software like Ubuntu Linux). Which means that expressed in simple terms, an effective remedy must also incorporate elements of balance - a balance between various differing, and at times mutually inconsistent, individual and social interests.

In this light, let us examine the nature of the present injunction. First, it was ex parte in character. Since such orders override a fundamental principle of natural justice that all parties should be given a fair hearing, they are to be issued with much restraint, and only in exceptional situations (such as when the other party persistently fails to appear, or when any delay will lead to significant injustice).

Secondly, the only specific parties the order names (at p. 3-4) are some fifteen India-based ISPs, whom it proceeds to restrain "from in any manner infringing the applicant's copyright in the cinematographic film/motion picture '3' . . .." No mention is made of any P2P or even video sharing sites, whose direct involvement in infringing the plaintiffs' copyright is much more feasible and also likelier. As a Medianama report correctly points out, ISPs are only intermediaries, and cannot by themselves infringe an copyrights. (It also says the order makes ISPs responsible for infringing copyright. Admittedly it does refer to certain other suit documents which are not in my possession right now, and hence whose content cannot be verified. However, to my mind there is nothing in the order at least that holds ISPs responsible for copyright infringement. It is as absurd as holding taxi drivers responsible for infringing UB's intellectual property merely by driving passengers to beer sharing venues.)

But it is the third characteristic of the order that makes it so remarkable. Apart from the ISPs mentioned, it specifies five other parties all denoted by the fictitious name "Ashok Kumar", and then also "other unknown persons", against whom the injunction applies. In many legal systems, particularly western ones, this is known as a "John Doe" order. Its use in India is rare. Even in the west it remains something of a novelty, but its use there is certainly more frequent than in India. As a result some jurisprudence has developed around around it, mainly in the nature of safeguards preventing it from arbitrary application. The question that arises naturally here how the present injunction fares when evaluated against these safeguards.

The most frequent use of the John Doe concept is not really relevant to us. It is when fictitious names like John Doe or Jane Roe are used to mask the identity of parties who cannot be named for concerns of privacy or other legal factors: examples include victims of rape or other sexual offences, parties who are underage and so on. More applicable to our case are instances when an injunction or some other relief is sought in regard to a person or persons unknown. This is gaining popularity internationally in intellectual property cases. An interesting example concerns Harry Potter books. The release of each volume in the series was greated with much public frenzy and, inevitably, media hype. This resulted in at least two separate cases of pre-publication copies being stolen with the intention of leaking to the tabloid press. On both occasions, an injunction was issued prohibiting person or persons unknown from "disclosing any information concerning the book or dealing in any way with any copies of the book or disclosing any part of any copies they might have to any third parties . . .." The first time it happened, before the launch of "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix" (volume 5), the injunction pertained specifically to the unidentified individuals who had offered the illicit copy to the Sun, the Daily Mail and the Daily Mirror. When it happened again with the next volume "Half-Blood Prince", the resultant injunction covered "any person or persons who have or have had physical possession of a copy  . . . or any part thereof without the consent of the claimants." What is significant here is that such injunctions have always been issued with a great deal of caution. Even the second Potter injunction was very specific in its application (i.e. the content of "Half-Blood Prince"); entailed a clearly defined  timeframe (from 3 June 2005, when the threat of leakage was detected, till 12.01 AM on 16 July, when the book was released); and pertained to individuals, albeit unknown, whose actions amounted to a direct and tangible copyright breach.

Similarly, take John Doe subpoenas popular in US, which are designed to compel disclosure of parties' identities, and are popular in cases of online defamation as well as copyright infringement. Since the net provides considerable scope for anonymous libel, obtaining the perpetrator's identity is usually a complicated process that involves first securing a court order (specifically, a subpoena) directing the hosting website to disclose the IP address from which the defamatory statement was made, and then securing another order this time directing the ISP that owns the address to reveal which account used that address at the time the statement was made.

This process is not only cumbersome, but also potentially infringes the privacy of the unnamed person. Consequently, courts have always been careful about issuing such subpoenas, and in various judgments formulated different tests and criteria to ascertain if a subpoena is appropriate. In Sony Music Entertainment Inc. v. Does 1-40 (326 F. Supp. 2d 556 (2004)), which in fact concerned copyright infringement through p2p networks, a New York district court held that a subpoena to disclose the identity of the file-sharers can be issued only if a prima facie case is made out against specific persons, no other means of obtaining their identity is possible and so on. This apporoach was followed in Doe v. Cahill (884 A.2d 451 (2005)), a Delaware Supreme Court concerning online defamation. Here the court ruled that no subpoena may be issued unless the plaintiff first demonstrates that the impugned comments can be "capable of a defamatory meaning". Subsequent cases have held that even after this prima facie test is satisfied, the plaintiff's interests must be balanced with those of the anonymous defendant. In Mobilisa, Inc. v. Doe (170 P. 3d 712 (2007)), the Arizona Appellate court followed Cahill and the older New Jersey decision of Dendrite International v. Doe No. 3 (A-2774-00T3 (2001)) to conclude that that even after the plaintiff establishes a prima facie case, a further set of five criteria must be fulfilled. For example, the plaintiff must make reasonable efforts to inform the anonymous party that a request to disclose anonymity exists; the intimation must be made through the same medium as the statement imputed to be defamatory, and so on.

All this serves to illustrate one crucial point: In jurisdictions where the law of copyright is much more matured as compared to India, John Doe injunctions are issued very judiciously, and by balancing the interests of all parties concerned - even the anonymous ones. Moreover, in most of the cases we saw, John Doe injunctions are issued subsequent to the commission of a legal wrong, not to pre-emptively restrain persons from committing them. In exceptions to this (such as the Harry Potter case), the terms of the injunction are tightly defined. These characteristics do not hold true for India. Once earlier also, the Delhi High Court had issued a similar John Doe injunction blocking the illegal distribution of the Reliance Big Pictures' film Singham before its official release (a copy of the order is available here). Since the injunction was not targetted at any specific individual, Reliance interpreted it to mean it could serve notices to anyone it wanted. So it went about serving cease and desist notices on both ISPs and torrent sites directly. The latter strategy did not work, since most of them lay outside the jurisdiction of Indian courts. The owner of BitSnoop, for example, made it clear that he had every intention to ignore the notice. Hence, presumably, when Copyright Labs decided to obtain a John Doe injunction, it made specific mention only of ISPs, who at worst can only aid the infringement of copyrighted materials by allowing subscribers to access them.

To conclude, let us revert to the question posed much earlier: can certain procedures otherwise uncalled for be justified merely because the subject matter concerns intellectual property? While it is manifest that the differences between beer and cinema call for dissimilar treatment, our above exegesis makes it equally clear that regardless of the nature of the subject, a balance must be maintained between different legitimate interests. Harish Ram, CEO of Copyright Labs, has claimed that ISPs had misinterpreted the order, and that the Labs' intention was only to block specific URLs. This explanation does not hold water. The ISPs acted not directly on the court order, but on the legal notice based on it that the Labs had sent them. It was therefore incumbent on the latter to be clear about what they were seeking.

Then again, perhaps questions like what the notice actually contained and whether or not the misunderstanding on the part of the ISPs was caused by ambiguities in the legal notice, do not really matter. Even if the wording of the notice contains no shortcomings, one grave issue still remains. It is respectfully submitted that by granting injunctions of such width, the Delhi and Madras High Courts have not taken due regard of this balance. To the extent that they have granted to the plaintiffs what amounts to a carte blanche to send cease and desist notices to anyone they fancy.  A strategy that upholds one interest to the exclusion of others is necessarily flawed. And that is why, given the way in which sites were blocked, the Kolaveri generated by the entire episode was perhaps inevitable.
Read more...

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

Concerning Record Labels, Big and Small

Mooching around in music shops is nowhere as much fun as it once was. For one, they have become very noisy places. For another, the old culture of choosing several records and asking them to play each one a bit before making one's final selection, or even walking away, has completely disappeared. Back in my college days, HMV House on Brigade Road, Bangalore had a separate room for classical music where people could listen to their selections in relative quietude before making their purchases. Today, if you request the sales personnel to play a recording before you've paid for it, they react like you're asking to defile its chastity or something.

What hurts even more is the jaded Hindustani music selections shops invariably seem to have on offer these days. Recordings of the great masters are invariably stuff ripped off a highly restricted set of vinyl releases and then recycled and repackaged ad nauseam. One company's marketing team has now started re-releasing old tracks in CDs painted black to resemble their long-playing progenitors. I suppose this '60s-retro look-'n'-feel in vogue now is a natural progression of the "ethnic chic" marketing ethos that dominated the classical music world in the '80s and '90s - remember those "Morning Raagaas" and "Evening Raagaas" [sic] compliations? New releases, on the other hand, are simply unappetising - more than anything else a reflection of the stranglehold star progeny and gimmick-artistes have over the music scene generally. And the prices! With file-sharing so widespread these days, I simply cannot understand why record labels still think selling at 300 to 500 Rupees something any enterprising enthusiast can download for free is a good idea. Or is it that they have given up on classical music piracy and decided bilking tourists and other narks makes for a more efficient business model?

Fortunately, not every company feels necessary to abase itself to this extent. I discovered this the other day at the Begumpet, Hyderabad Landmark outlet. To give them their due,  the Landmark people do strive for a more meaningful balance between saleable glitz and the stuff people like me want to hear. Unfortunately this effort does not quite come off, due mainly to the dearth of interesting recordings available. So I was less than enthusiastic about spending some two hours there, which I had to do because the wife and I had volunteered to take some friends from Bangladesh shopping. The book section yielded a few interesting finds, but nothing in the must-buy-right-now-come-what-may class. So I gravitated towards the music section eventually, and with no real expectations of finding anything of much interest.

My initial desultory survey seemed to confirm this pessimism, when I came across this bunch of CDs tucked away in a corner. It was easy to see why they hadn't been given much prominence; the surrounding honk and glamour made their cheap production values look even more shabby. They didn't aspire to jewel boxes, merely stiff paper envelopes containing disks sheathed in clear polythene packets. In fact, they weren't even CDs in the proper sense, as I found once I got back home. But for thirty Rupees a disk, and of music of this quality, I'd cheerfully forgo the bells and whistles.

The Lahari label is pretty obscure even in its hometown Bangalore, but I had encountered it once earlier. Back in 1994 I had bought two cassettes of Basavaraj Rajguru, one featuring Shuddha Sarang and Maru Bihag, and the other Komal Rishab Asuvari [sic], Nayyaki [sic] Kanada and a Khamaz [sic] tumri [sic]. The abysmal production values extended to other areas too, with more serious consequences. The cheapo tape stock they used began to give out within a short time, and ultimately became unplayable altogether. All these years I had been looking for replacements, with little success. So I was nothing less than delighted to discover they have now been reissued as CDs and, what's more, priced at thirty Rupees the same as the rest. Then there was a gorgeous Bilaskhani Todi and Kalavati by Parameshwar Hegde. I have long held the belief he's one of India's most underrated vocalists today, and this release merely reinforces my opinion. The other vocal stuff on offer wasn't so interesting; mostly second-string vocalists from Dharwad and Vinayak Torvi acolytes. The instrumental section also contained a big surprise: three releases, no less, by the Harmonium wizard Rambhau Bijapure. I confess I'm not a big fan of Harmonium solos, but the one CD I've listened to so far (Nat Bhairav and Sur Malhar) was a genuine pleasure, as were the Parameshwar Hegde and the two Basavarajes. They all deserve detailed exegeses, and I intend to review them individually as and when time permits. For now, let me venture a few comments on the enterprise in general.

Pricing CDs so low is always a good idea. It contributes immensely to the propagation of music, especially the high-quality music their lineup boasts. In the bargain it also serves as a more ethical alternative to piracy. But if you are really serious about all this, not to mention about selling your products, the least you can do is provide proper information about your range of releases? I'd say this problem is endemic across Indian labels. The last time HMV (as it then was) came up with a really well-produced catalogue was back in 1982. The present Saregama website is a marvel of ambiguity. Others like  Music Today's site are not particularly better. Lahari trumps them all; it eschews a web presence altogether! Forget about its own website, even the email address printed on the CD envelopes belongs to the vsnl.com domain. As a result, nobody's quite sure of what they have on offer. My second gripe is with availability and distribution. In the past, small labels found it almost impossible to have their releases marketed across record stores. Today, record stores, and also big publishers and distribution networks, are themselves facing a fadeout. Online distribution as pioneered in India by the likes of Flipkart is a huge game-changer, should I say a game-leveller. All of a sudden, marketing clout and distribution infrastructure have ceased to matter. The problem is, companies like Lahari don't see it that way. Despite several searches I could not find out if any online retailer, Flipkart or otherwise, stocks their releases. As it is, their presence in chains like Westside is marginal. And lastly, on an unrelated note, how about improving production quality a little? In point of fact, the releases are not even CDs in the proper sense, but merely CD-Rs whose useful life is limited by the quality of the dyes used in their production. The Basavaraja release cover designs border on the grotesque: one of them features a colour photograph of the maestro, with a kind of halo surrounding his head, set off against a background of purple, blue and magenta plasmae. The track listings are spelled even more uh, radically than they were in the cassette releases: Volume Two now features (1) Komal Rishabh - Raag: Asuvari; (2) Kamaaz Rishabh - Raag: Tumri; and (3) Nayyaki - Raag: Kannada. Worse, the track order seems to have scrambled itself in the CD - the Nayyaki is labelled Track 1, followed by the Tumri and then Asuwari. The Rambhau releases are much better produced - cleaner design, properly written track listings, even a brief biographical passage included on the reverse side.

To conclude, what is the point of this diatribe? It is merely that companies like Lahari can achieve a lot. They have some very interesting recordings on offer (like I said, more on them later). They also have a ready market, comprising serious listeners. And today, online shopping has made redundant a lot of marketing and distribution nonsense. In short, the time is ripe for smaller players to step in and supply serious music at affordable prices, something big labels have conspicuously avoided so far.

Well, not exactly. The times, they do seem to be a-changin' after all. Flipkart's come out with its own digital music store, apparently undertaken in collaboration with the biggies. Individual tracks sell for between Rupees six and fifteen, full albums for less than a hundred, usually around fifty to seventy. Take this Gajananrao Joshi CD I spotted at Landmark, priced at Rs. 295 which I thought was way too much. Flipkart offers the entire album in the form of 320 kbps mp3 downloads, at a total cost of Rs. 69. So all this while we've been paying Rs. 295-69 = 226 for the CD media, the jewel case, inlay cards, distribution, shelf space at the retailers and other essential if somewhat peripheral expenses. This is outrageous even by modern marketing standards - imagine McDonalds charging Rs. 69 for a hamburger, and Rs. 295 for the same thing with a coke and fries thrown in?

So this digital music store's a worthwhile idea after all, right? Actually, no. And for a reason we ought to have guessed. If the biggies are involved, can slapdash production values be far behind? Track listings, track lengths, album details and other metadata are provided so chaotically it gets difficult to ascertain just what you're buying, particularly whether you'll end up purchasing duplicates of what you already have. We clearly have a long, long way to go.
Read more...

Monday, 30 June 2008

NCPA and the Sell-out of Heritage - III: The System and the Small Guy


NCPA and the Sell-out of Heritage
Part III - The System and the Small Guy


[This is the third in a series of articles on NCPA's recent move to commercialise its archival resources. Here Abhik takes a look at the "system" - the state, big business, large research bodies - and how much, or how little, it has done for the small guy.]

1. Introduction

Lots could be said on the ethics of commercialisation. Particularly on how control shifts seamlessly from the government to big business. This has happened so many times before. And each time the small guy has been short-changed in the process. The present instance, the commercialisation of the NCPA archives, is only one of the more recent examples. In this article, I discuss the functioning of a few such institutions in India.


2. Copyrights

India is waking up to the money-spinning potential of copyrights. As different interest-groups struggle to come to terms with it, bystanders can get to see some truly bizarre developments.

The Indian Premier League (IPL) has taken the lead in securing its rights. So much so that at one point the media, staggered by the stringent conditions imposed on it, even contemplated boycotting the circus altogether. Once the tournament got underway, it was the League's turn at the receiving end of intellectual property laws. Teams faced legal action for playing copyrighted music without permission.

Overenthusiastic use of copyright laws has led to other developments also. For one, the high cost of licensing is being blamed for the declining amounts of music aired on TV channels. The same high fees are also reportedly eroding the financial viability of commercial FM channels.

A report carried by DNA accuses the music industry of imposing steep royalties to offset dwindling album sales due to piracy. It quotes a Saregama executive as explaining the question of reducing royalties did not arise, as FM channels have not helped the cause of Indian music:
When the first phase of FM radio begun, we thought it would give a fillip to musicians by promoting various genres of music. However, nothing of that sort has happened. Instead, all you see is about 150-odd FM stations, all playing the same Bollywood music in the Top 20 format.
This claim would have been much more believable had the recording industry not used the precise opposite argument to justify its own high revenues from album sales.

Saragama is a leading member of the Indian Music Industry (IMI), the nation's premier lobby-group for the industry. According to IMI's website, "When revenue from top selling hits is lost to piracy, companies cannot afford to invest in specialist areas and offer consumers a wider selection of music."

So on the one hand, high revenues are justified as necessary for providing diversity; and on the other hand, FM channels have steep royalties slapped on them because they do not provide enough diversity! Given the pitiful lack of diversity in Saregama's own catalogue (high revenues notwithstanding), one fears to ask them if they plan to reduce royalties for channels actually "helping the cause of music."

Which leads to the question, if this is the conditions faced by commercial broadcasters, what is the condition of community radio organisations? Royalties comprise a big obstacle. While American copyright societies charge low-power FM stations about Rs. 5.73 per hour of music, Indian societies levy something like Rs. 480!

3. Community Radio

Matter of fact, community radio forms another classic instance of small guys getting marginalised. The report referred to above states some more interesting facts. Broadcasters can buy transmitters only from two government-approved companies, both selling their products at Rs. 1.5 - 2 lakhs. Also, they must not carry any "news" reports. The problem here is, what constitutes "news" is not defined or specified.

We have seen how quickly the liberalisation of airwaves translated into commercial FM broadcasts. Community radio has not been so lucky; it has barely got off the ground, and the state is doing nothing to help. As a commentator put it, "Does the government of India trust Rupert Murdoch more than its own citizens?" (Incidentally, the quote is taken from this article, which I recommend highly as a concise summary of all that is wrong with broadcasting in India.)

In 1995, the Supreme Court held in Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting v. Cricket Association of Bengal that airwaves are public property [para 47] and that the right to communicate implict in the right to freedom of speech (Article 19(1)(a)) includes the right to broadcast over airwaves [para 44]. Consequently, in 2002 the government announced a policy change. By 2006 it had brought out guidelines twice over. In 2007 the I&B Secretary claimed no less than 4000 stations will be established in the next few years.

Initially, the developments were received with considerable enthusiasm in both mainstream and non-mainstream media. This very quickly gave way to disillusionment, as activists awoke to the reality of red tape and prohibitive costs. It also became clear that the government had no intention of letting go of control. As a bureaucrat is reported to have explained at a conference:
See, private radio broadcasting is just an 8-year-old baby in India. It’s in its infancy and so we have to advice (sic) the child, ‘Do this . . . please don’t do this . . ..’ Once you mature, we’ll give you leeway . . . but you have to prove yourself mature; please exercise self-regulation.

4. Copyright Societies

So far we have seen copyrights used by the big guys against other big guys. The law of copyright is not indifferent to the the interests of the small guy. It contemplates the establishment of copyright societies or collectives, whose job is to enforce rights and obtain royalties on behalf of individual right-holders. In Indian law, Part VII of the Copyright Act, 1957, covering Sections 33 to 36-A, deals with copyright societies.

The Indian Copyright Office site provides a list of copyright societies presently functioning in India. It lists all of four societies:
  • Cinematographic films: Society for Copyright Regulation of Indian Producers for Film and Television (SCRIPT) (no official website yet)
  • Musical works: Indian Performing Right Society Limited (IPRS)
  • Sound recordings: Phonographic Performance Limited (PPL)
  • Reprographic works: Indian Reprographic Rights Organization (IRRO)
  • Another one, the Indian Copyright Society (ICRS), which is mentioned in the list, appears to be an umbrella organisation of sorts. Its website advertises "single-window" clearance of copyright licensing, but does not say much beyond that, especially about the Society's antecedents.
Three out of the first four have deep, pervasive links with the big guys. Little is known about SCRIPT, but the name itself suggests an organisation of producers, i.e. big guys. PPL was created by members of the Indian Phonographic Industry (IPI), which in 1994 changed its name to IMI. IRRO was formed with the active participation of the Authors Guild of India and the Federation of Indian Publishers, the first an organisation for small guys, and the second for big guys. It is not known how effectively IRRO protects authors' interests in respect of big-guy publishers. The site mentions virtually nothing of its activities.

IPRS seems to be the only organisation created to genuinely uphold the interests of small guys. According to its website, it was established in 1969 by the left-leaning composer and trade-unionist M B Sreenivasan, with the help of lyricist Naqsh Lyallpuri. Its former directors include composers Salil Choudhury, Laxmikant (Kudalkar),P Ramesh Naidu, Naushad and M S Viswanathan; lyricists R N Jayagopal, Kannadasan, O N V Kurup and Majrooh Sultanpuri; singer-composers Hemanta Mukherjee and Sudhir Phadke, and even actor I S Johar.

In the 1990s it transformed itself, and appointed as executives dedicated professionals from the younger generation. Recently it has been in the news for initiating proceedings against IPL to secure the interests of its members.

India still lacks a performer's rights society. IPRS is a performing rights society. It protects the interests of writers, lyricists and composers, licensing their performances in exchange for royalties. It does not protect the interests of the performers themselves.

Organisations abroad like the Canadian Alliance of Canadian Cinema, Television and Radio Artists (ACTRA) play a major role in securing performer's rights. In the financial year 2006-07, ACTRA disbursed as much as $9 million to its members.

5. Conclusion

Radio stations, record companies, copyright societies, and music archives. I discuss them together not for similarities in their area of functioning; it has more to do with the way the have functioned in India for so many years.

Short-changing the small guy started with the licence raj. It shut out entrepreneural opportunities to all but a chosen few. The liberalisation process demonstrated that neglect of the small guy has nothing to do with the system of governance. No matter if it's the sarkari babu or the corporate executive at the helm, the small guy gets short-changed regardless.

All-India Radio owns by far the most extensive archives in the nation. In the sixty-odd years since independence, it has consistently denied outsiders access to its archives.. Now it is also taking steps to commercially release its recordings. So is the Sangeet Natak Akademi.

The Akademi's archival access record is only marginally better. Though officially it is open to all members, it is subject to frequent operational delays typical of government-run institutions in India. Privately run archives have their own access-related issues. It has been the experience of some that bodies like NCPA and ARCE-AIIS are actually more receptive to the needs of foreigners (read westerners) than Indian scholars!

Intellectual property laws do not constitute a solution. A ponderous judiciary not entirely corruption-free jacks up legal costs, thereby ipso facto tilting the scale against the small guys. This is even if you discount the powerful lobby-groups big guys control. Even under ideal conditions, it can protect only some small guys, like performers and composers.

What about the interests of the rasik? In most art-music traditions, the role of an informed audience is no less important than that of the performers themselves. And yet they seem to be perpetually getting the short end of the stick. Patchily distributed albums at inflated prices, barred access to archives, sloppy broadcast organisations, the industry-wide craze for big-draw names at the expense of musical excellence, these are only some the obstacles Indian rasiks keep facing.

And yet it is because of the small guys, the creators, the performers and their audience, that music is alive today. Everything else, recording companies, government-run cultural agencies, broadcast channels and music archives equally, play only a peripheral role in the production and consumption of music (if I may resort to such soul-destroying terminology).

The tragedy today, therefore, is that these peripheral players, coincidentally the big guys, predominate over the small guys. In the process, so do their interests take precedence over that which nourishes the life of music.

[back to prefatory note and list of articles]
Read more...

Wednesday, 25 June 2008

NCPA and the Sell-out of Heritage - Prefatory Note

The National Centre for the Performing Arts (NCPA) is moving towards the commercial exploitation of its archival recordings. The manner in which it has gone about it suggests a low priority accorded to the interests of music and musicians. We at the DSS Blog respond here with a series of articles that explore the various aspects of this issue in its larger context.

NCPA's preparations are indeed extensive. It has floated a tender seeking partnerships from the music industry, and also appointed as Arts Management Consultant one Owen Mortimer from the consultancy group C-Sharp. (Owen, presently also a director of the Rajasthan International Folk Festival, was earlier associated with the Les Azuriales Opera Festival and the Association of British Orchestras (ABO) as Acting Projects Manager.)

Strangely enough, it is only after undertaking these steps that it has started informing concerned artistes. On 13 June 2008 it circulated an e-mail on this venture, the text of which is nothing more than a copy/paste of the tender mentioned above.e

This casual treatment gives credence to apprehensions that the venture accords low priority to the interests of music and musicians. It also makes one wonder how serious they are about their promise made in the tender about conducting the venture "with strict adherence to intellectual property rights and all prevailing laws applicable for their legitimate release."

Not unnaturally, these developments have evoked great dismay in the musicians' community. Some have already already placed on record their strong reservation about the venture. The media, though, has yet to catch. An extensive web-search yielded not a single newspaper report on the issue.

We at the DSS Blog feel that the project is not only a cause of concern in itself, it also raises larger questions about the commercialisation of cultural heritage. In response, we present here a series of articles that examine this and other related developments, together with their larger ethical, legal, historical, economic and other implications.

This prefatory note also features a list of posts in the series. Other articles, as and when they are posted, will be hyperlinked to it.
  1. Overview - Arnab Chakrabarty
  2. Legal Implications - Abhik Majumdar
  3. The System and the Small Guy - Abhik Majumdar
Read more...